Should We Give In To Clickbait When Creating Content?

Posted on Posted in Writing

Clickbait. It’s the bane of web content and seems to everywhere these days, should content marketers be using clickbait in their titles to draw attention to their content though?

Online content is predicted to increase by 600% by 2020 and Mark Schaefer has already coined the term ‘content shock’ back in 2014 and discussed how web users and our audience are going to be drowing in content soon. This has resulted in content creators choosing to use clickbait in their titles while others are claiming they are forced to do it as otherwise no-one sees or shares their content.

What Is Clickbait?

Clickbait is a term that most web users will most likely know by now. Google defines it as the following:

“…content, especially that of a sensational or provocative nature, whose main purpose is to attract attention and draw visitors to a particular web page.”

That makes it sound relatively harmless right? Wikipedia’s definition isn’t exactly in full agreement though:

“…web content that is aimed at generating online advertising revenue, especially at the expense of quality or accuracy, relying on sensationalist headlines or eye-catching thumbnail pictures to attract click-throughs and to encourage forwarding of the material over online social networks. Clickbait headlines typically aim to exploit the “curiosity gap”, providing just enough information to make the reader curious, but not enough to satisfy their curiosity without clicking through to the linked content.”

6de

Recently, YouTuber Felix Kjellberg or ‘Pewdiepie’ published a video showing him watching clickbait videos and summarizing them so we ‘won’t have to click on them’, the video was of course mainly in jest but it did highlight just how bad some of the very popular video content out there is and the lengths they go to with their titles just to get someone to click on it and view the video.

What he said later on in the video was quite sobering though:

“Clickbaiting: Almost everyone does it. If you don’t do it, you’re not going to get views. I can spend days on a video and it will get less views than a video that we did in 10 minutes that has a better title. YouTube is really unfair in that regard, and what it leads to is good content sometimes getting buried by ‘clickable’ content.” 

Felix has by far the biggest Youtube channel with over 46m subscribers and his new videos will often hit 1m views within just a few hours of them being published, so for him to admit that even he has to resort to clickbait titles then it says a lot about the content landscape currently. He goes on to say that it’s a major issue with Youtube content and online media in general. Check his video out below.

Facebook were one of the first major platforms to start the fight back against clickbait. In 2014 they started making changes to their algorithm so that content that was only viewed for very short lengths of time by Facebook users would show up less and less in their feeds, they also put more emphasis on serving a users friends and family content in their feed and less from business pages. With another update to this algorithm just recently, many business pages are lucky to get even a 3% reach to their audience now (without paying that is).

All of this this means that the places where we can push our content to audiences organically is becoming more crowded and competitive, what can we do to stand out from the noise? Should we be using clickbait in our titles too?

Although the Wikipedia definition paints clickbait in a bad light it does also mention things such as ‘curiosity gap’ and ‘make the reader curious’ both of which are all good copywriters and marketers should be using in their titles. The term ‘curiosity gap’ was actually first coined in the mid 1990’s long before social media (or content marketing as we know it) existed, George Lowenstein a US economics and psychology academic published a paper on the topic in 1994.

“Curiosity has been consistently recognized as a critical motive that influences human behavior in positive and negative ways at all stages of the life cycle. It has been identified as a driving force in child development and as one of the most important spurs of educational attainment.”

George Lowenstien, Psychological bulletin, 1994

Curiosity is something that markets and copywriters have been using for decades and our job as modern day content creators and story tellers is to pull our audience into our content and away from someone else’s. Smart copywriters can use these tactics to draw the user into their copy and keep them engaged there. If your content fulfills the the curiosity that the reader had when seeing the title then it is not clickbait!

Playing on the audience’s emotions, feelings and curiosity is a natural part of copywriting and content creation and should not be shied away from. Some good examples are:

  • Keeping back information in the title, which can only be obtained within the full content
  • Starting a story
  • Introducing a new idea or an idea that goes against established beliefs or attitudes
  • An unexpected outcome

So when do we know if it’s ok or not to use clickbait in our titles? If you are unsure whether it’s suitable or not, ask yourself these questions first:

How is the audience going to feel after reading this content?

Is my content delivering what is promised within the title?

How will this affect my brands integrity and reputation?

What do I want the user to do once they have finished reading this content?

If the reader is not going to find the answer to what brought them into your content then they are going to be unhappy and leave the page, they may or may not return but if this is happening with hundreds or thousands of users then eventually this is going to have a damaging affect on your brand and authority. As mentioned above Facebook have already started to combat this and Google have for many years preferred ‘long clicks’ over short ones.

Using clickbait the right way can add extra weight to already compelling content, as this video demonstrates perfectly.

What are your thoughts on clickbait?

6 thoughts on “Should We Give In To Clickbait When Creating Content?

  1. I think clickbait is nice if people find in the post what they are looking for, often it’s not the case and that piss of everybody !

  2. Hi David,

    It was a completely new word for me. Click bait!
    With the example of facebook you clearly define how the competition has emerged really tough for any marketer. Without proper strategy it is most likely that the content is not reached to large audiences.
    I like the way you have explained to maintain and engage customer interaction with help of emotions.
    Satisfying customer needs is also important point to remember.
    Thanks for such a helpful post.
    With regards,
    Saurav

  3. Hi David,

    That’s really great. Clickbait is an awesome idea to attract targeted audience to our website. I personally believe that if you provide value to your readers and give them what they were actually looking for, they will surely link and promote your content or service. Thanks for this incredible post. I learned a lot from videos 🙂

  4. It’ll be interesting to see what comes after click bait titles – I mean, I don’t think people will “fall for” click bait titles forever, will they? It would seem at some point most people will just roll their eyes at every “You Won’t Believe His Reaction” instead of actually clicking on it, if for no other reason than they’re now aware they’re being baited.

    Or maybe the bait is just too strong…

  5. Thanks for sharing me what click bait really means. Most web users don’t know much about click bait. I admit this kind of strategy is really effective to capture the audience’s attention. Most of the time, I used to read the caption first before I click the certain link.

  6. Content strategy is meant to draw users to your website, this is not always easy as any content marketer would attest, but taking a shortcut (ClickBait) by deceiving a user will not pay off in the long run.

Comments are closed.